Skip to content

How to cut online ordering costs by 25%

Marketplaces take 25% of every order. Here’s how to keep that money in-house without losing sales or upsetting customers.

By The Berryin Team10 min read
A hand uses a touchscreen digital payment system to process a receipt at a cafe.

Online ordering costs you 25% per sale—here’s how to stop that bleeding

Marketplaces and aggregators take a cut of every order, but the real cost is what you lose when customers never return. A branded ordering website keeps the commission, the data and the repeat business—but only if it works as well as the apps customers already use. The difference between a storefront that drives sales and one that becomes a ghost page is how you handle three things: checkout friction, mobile experience and the kitchen workflow. Get any of those wrong, and you’ll pay for it in abandoned baskets, kitchen chaos and lost customers.

The first rule is simple: your ordering site must be faster than the marketplaces. Not faster than your old website, faster than Uber Eats or Deliveroo. If a customer opens your site and it takes more than three seconds to load, they’ll close it and go to the app they already trust. That’s not just lost sales—it’s lost data. You’ll never know why they left, and you’ll never see them again.

The second rule is just as critical: the kitchen must see orders before the customer leaves the checkout. No waiting for an email, no manual entry, no “I’ll get to it later.” If your kitchen display doesn’t update in real time, you’re turning online orders into a second, slower queue—and that’s money you’re not earning.

Here’s the worked example. Say you sell a £12 burger with 30% food cost (£3.60) and 20% labour (£2.40). That leaves £6 gross profit. A marketplace takes 25% (£3), leaving you £3 net. Now say you move that order to your own site. You keep the full £6, but you also avoid the £1.50 delivery fee the customer would have paid (which you’d have to cover or pass on). That’s £7.50 per order—125% more profit—without raising prices or cutting quality.

But here’s where most restaurants trip up. They build a nice-looking site, then assume customers will find it. They don’t. Your storefront needs to be where your customers already are. That means:

  • A mobile-optimised site that loads in under a second on 3G (because that’s what most of your customers use).
  • A WhatsApp button if you’re in Pakistan, or a direct link from your Instagram bio if you’re in the UK.
  • A checkout that remembers the customer’s details—no forms, no retyping, no friction.

If you skip any of those, you’re leaving money on the table. And if your kitchen can’t handle the volume without breaking, you’ll lose more than just the commission.

The hidden cost of slow checkouts

Abandoned baskets aren’t just a problem for e-commerce—they’re a killer for restaurants too. 30% of online orders are lost at checkout, and most of those customers never come back. The reason? Too many steps, too much typing, or a page that takes too long to load. If your checkout has more than four fields, you’re losing sales. If it doesn’t save the customer’s details for next time, you’re losing loyalty.

Here’s how it plays out in real time:

  1. A customer adds a £15 meal to their basket.
  2. They click ‘Checkout’ and see a form asking for name, phone, address, postcode, payment details—and a captcha.
  3. They pause. Their phone battery is at 12%. The Wi-Fi drops out.
  4. They switch to Deliveroo instead.

You’ve just lost £15, but more importantly, you’ve lost a customer who might have spent £100 over the next year. The cost of a slow checkout isn’t just the sale—it’s the lifetime value of that customer.

The fix? A one-click checkout. Save the customer’s details the first time they order, then let them tap a single button next time. No forms, no retyping, no friction. If you’re using a system that doesn’t do this automatically, you’re paying for it in lost sales every day.

And here’s the edge case most restaurants miss: mobile users abandon checkouts at twice the rate of desktop users. If your site isn’t optimised for phones, you’re losing twice as many sales as you think. Test your checkout on a mid-range Android phone with a slow data connection. If it takes more than five seconds to load, you’ve got a problem.

How to move customers off marketplaces—without begging

You don’t need to beg customers to switch. You just need to make it easier for them to stay with you. The key is convenience. If your ordering process is faster, cheaper or more reliable than the marketplaces, customers will choose you—eventually.

Here’s how to pull it off:

  • Offer a discount for direct orders. Not a “buy one, get one free” gimmick, but a real saving. Say you normally charge £5 delivery. On your own site, make it £3. That’s £2 extra profit per order, and it gives customers a reason to switch.

  • Let them order ahead. Marketplaces don’t handle pre-orders well. Your site should. If customers can schedule a meal for tomorrow at lunch, they’ll use your system instead of waiting for a marketplace slot.

  • Give them a loyalty reward. If they order three times in a month on your site, give them a free dessert. No points, no apps—just a simple “order again and we’ll cover it” message. It works because it’s easy.

The biggest mistake? Thinking customers will switch overnight. It takes three to five orders on your site before a customer feels comfortable enough to ditch the marketplaces. Your job is to make those first three orders as frictionless as possible.

And here’s the trade-off you’ll face: the more discounts you offer, the lower your margins. But the alternative is losing 25% of every sale to a marketplace. Do the math. If you’re selling £100 of food a day, moving even 10% of those orders to your own site saves you £25—before you factor in the repeat business.

What breaks when you switch to your own ordering

Moving off marketplaces isn’t just about saving money—it’s about controlling your own destiny. But that control comes with risks. Here’s what goes wrong when restaurants switch, and how to stop it:

  • Kitchen chaos. If your orders don’t sync in real time, the kitchen will get overwhelmed. A sudden spike in online orders without warning leads to delays, remakes and angry customers. The fix? A kitchen display that updates every time a new order comes in—and alerts staff when the queue gets too long.

  • Lost data. Marketplaces give you basic numbers, but your own system should track exactly what customers order, when they order it, and how much they spend. If you’re not using that data to upsell or retarget, you’re leaving money on the table.

  • Payment failures. If your checkout doesn’t handle declined cards smoothly, you’ll lose sales. The solution? Offer multiple payment methods—card, mobile wallet, even cash on delivery if that’s how your customers pay. And make sure the system retries failed payments automatically.

  • Customer confusion. Some customers will still try to order through marketplaces. You need a way to redirect them—either with a clear message on your site (“Order faster and cheaper here”) or by blocking marketplace listings entirely.

The biggest failure mode? Assuming your existing staff can handle the switch. If your servers aren’t trained to manage online orders alongside dine-in, you’ll see delays, mistakes and complaints. Train them. Give them a cheat sheet. Make sure they know how to handle a rush of digital orders without dropping the ball on the front of house.

How much does this actually cost?

The numbers depend on where you are, but here’s the breakdown for a mid-sized restaurant:

Plan Monthly Cost (Pakistan) Monthly Cost (UK/AU) What You Get
Starter Rs 6,000 £90 Basic storefront, mobile-optimised checkout, WhatsApp orders (Pakistan), 1 branch.
Growth Rs 10,000 £180 Everything in Starter + pre-orders, loyalty rewards, 2 branches.
Pro Rs 18,000 £280 Everything in Growth + advanced kitchen sync, multi-location management, API access.

Customized setups (for cloud kitchens, high-volume cafés or multi-city operations) are priced on request. Get in touch here.

Here’s the math for a £50,000-a-month turnover restaurant in the UK:

  • If you move 10% of sales (£5,000/month) from marketplaces to your own site, you save 25% commission (£1,250) plus delivery fees (another £750). That’s £2,000 extra profit per month—before you factor in repeat customers.

  • If you reduce abandoned baskets by 15% (from 30% to 15%), you recover another £750/month in lost sales.

  • Total extra profit: £2,750/month. That’s £33,000 a year—enough to hire an extra staff member or upgrade your kitchen.

The real cost isn’t the monthly fee—it’s the opportunity cost of not switching. If you’re still paying 25% to marketplaces, you’re leaving £12,500 a year on the table for every £50,000 in sales.

What happens three months in?

Most restaurants see three things change when they switch to their own ordering system:

  1. More repeat customers. Marketplaces treat every order as a one-off. Your system lets you recognise regulars and offer them personalised deals—like a “your usual” button for their favourite meal.

  2. Fewer kitchen mistakes. Real-time order sync means no more “I thought it was ready” moments. The kitchen sees the order, confirms it, and starts cooking—no delays, no remakes.

  3. Better data. You’ll know exactly what’s selling, what’s not, and when your busiest hours are. Use that to adjust your menu, staffing and marketing—not guesswork.

But here’s the catch: you’ll also see some customers drop off. Not because they don’t like your food, but because they’re used to the marketplace’s convenience. Your job is to replace that convenience with something better—faster checkout, cheaper delivery, or a loyalty reward they can’t get elsewhere.

The restaurants that succeed are the ones who treat their own ordering site like a marketplace—fast, reliable, and always improving. The ones that fail are the ones who treat it like an afterthought.

Do I need to build my own website, or can I use an existing one?

You don’t need to build from scratch. A branded ordering storefront (like the one linked here) gives you a mobile-optimised, marketplace-style experience without the 25% cut. It integrates with your existing POS, syncs orders to the kitchen in real time, and lets you accept payments—all in under a day. The key is not just having a website, but having one that converts as well as the apps customers already use.

What if my customers won’t switch from marketplaces?

They will—if you make it easier for them to stay with you. Start with a discount for direct orders (even £1 off delivery makes a difference). Then add pre-ordering, loyalty rewards and faster checkout. Most customers switch within three to five orders if the process is smoother than the marketplace.

How do I stop kitchen chaos when online orders spike?

Use a real-time kitchen display that updates every time a new order comes in. Set alerts for high-order volumes so staff can prep ahead, and train your team to prioritise digital orders without dropping the ball on dine-in service. The worst mistake? Assuming the kitchen can handle a sudden rush without any changes—it can’t.

Can I still use marketplaces if I have my own ordering system?

Yes, but only as a backup. Your own site should be the primary way customers order—marketplaces should be an option for those who still prefer them. The goal is to move as much volume as possible to your own channel, where you keep the full profit.

What’s the biggest mistake restaurants make when switching?

Assuming the switch will happen overnight. Most customers won’t abandon marketplaces after one order. You need a three-month plan: start with discounts, then add loyalty rewards, then retarget customers with ads for your faster, cheaper ordering experience. The restaurants that fail are the ones who stop promoting their own site after the first month.

If you’re ready to cut your online ordering costs by 25% and keep more of your sales in-house, start here. The first step is choosing a plan that fits your turnover—then we’ll get your storefront live in under a day.

#online-ordering-costs#marketplace-alternatives#restaurant-profit-boost#checkout-optimisation#customer-retention

Want to see this working on your own menu?

Book a free demo and we will set Berryin up with a slice of your real menu — ordering, POS, kitchen and reports, end to end.

Ready to run your restaurant smarter?

Book a free demo and see Berryin working with your own menu.

Chat on WhatsApp
Chat with us on WhatsApp